Bernini, Caravaggio, and Borromini

Sometimes we think we have a pretty good grasp on an artist’s work from the “famous” works that repeat over and over in textbooks, scholarly literature, and general information.  Then we spend some time in a place like Rome where their work is everywhere from the stairs you walk up, to the paintings they produced, to the domes they designed and you realized how little you knew and how bowled over you are by something you’ve never seen before.  And then of course, there is where you saw it, and that it is right in front of your face instead of on a page or a screen.  That’s the feeling we have had after the last few days of seeing these artists over and over again.  Any major museum in the world would be lucky and quite prestigious to have one or two Caravaggio’s or maybe a Bernini, though I suspect most of his work has stayed in Italy.  Borromini who is probably not familiar to most was mainly an architect and alternately a colleague of Bernini’s and a competitor.  Always interesting to get the back story.

Lastly, there are those things that you so looked forward to seeing in real life and then were so disappointed that it looked better in the pictures than in real life.  We had that experience as well though definitely not with Caravaggio.  I can’t begin to explain how extraordinary this man’s work was and he died at such a young age.  Most of the places we could not take photos inside so I’ll give you the links so you can see for yourself if you are so inclined:

Borghese and Barberini Galleries

Sta. Maria del Popolo (Caravaggio)

Cornaro Chapel(Bernini)

In the case of the two paintings by Caravaggio in Sta. Maria del Popolo, their placement in the tiny chapel is unbelievably powerful.  Both have foreshortened figures that look as if they will fall right into your arms.  These are two of Caravaggio’s most famous works and to have them here in such a relatively small church is remarkable and they are perfectly situated to make a dramatic impact.  On the other hand, the Bernini “St. Theresa” is in a shallow space that is so much smaller than it looks in photographs, is dingy, and poorly lit.  Someone said the window above that is supposed to cast dramatic light down on the figures is covered in grime- why wouldn’t someone clean it off?

3 thoughts on “Bernini, Caravaggio, and Borromini

  1. Ancient Roman Statue…which year(s) in ancient?; looks like commemorative political portraiture/sculpture with an emphasis or display of ancestry/family history…so amazing, isn’t it? Oh..oh, the everything…please take that Bernini walk, over a bridge, etc. for me…Bernini to the left, Bernini to the right. Have long wished to do that. Living vicariously is just fine, though, because your Poetry is so enjoyable; thank you!

  2. HI Mina–I really like the Bernini, of course, but my favorite Bernini is The Calling of St. Matthew. Don’t know if you will get to see it, but if you can, it is SO worth the trip. It was completed in 1599-1600 for the Contarelli Chapel in the church of the French congregation, San Luigi dei Francesi in Rome, where it remains today. It hangs alongside two other paintings of Matthew by Caravaggio. T

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s